Author: wingsfortruth2

WINGS Note: Dr Natalie Bolin, a co-author of this letter, is an Executive Director at Advocates For The Truth

---

May 12, 2024

Dear Friends and Workers,

First, we apologize in advance as this letter may be overwhelming with information/topics that you may or may not be aware of. It is a long letter, and yet barely scratches the surface. The intent is to bring awareness and education (resources at the end of this letter) to the worldwide Child Sexual Abuse (CSA) crisis within our fellowship. We ask that you read this letter in its entirety as we want to make very clear our stance about this situation. We know that many have not been made aware of the volume and depth of information that has come to light, and we feel it is important to communicate the basic facts and themes of conversations we are having with survivors and friends nationally and internationally. However, this letter cannot fully capture or relate the complexity of the situation. There are uncomfortable truths that must be acknowledged, discussed, and addressed so that our fellowship can begin to heal. People are not ok.

We wanted to include a brief synopsis of the current situation beginning with the exposure of Dean Bruer here, but there is no way to be brief about all that has come to light. If you are unaware of the details of the current crisis you can click here: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Ax6ma_0utHpMTfFz0EkkOuaAAawVT6_6nY8sAKSqWrw/edit

This is a link to a timeline (updated almost daily) of all that has come out since May 23, 2023. There are 23 pages of brief entries that create a timeline of events.

We are now in a worldwide crisis. On February 20, 2024, the Federal Bureau of Investigations (FBI) opened a national investigation into our church. Opening an FBI investigation is not a snap decision but a process, meaning a preliminary investigation was presented to a Grand Jury in Washington DC. Through the evidence produced by that preliminary investigation, the Grand Jury decided that there was enough evidence of criminal behavior for federal funds to be dedicated to opening a hotline, along with multiple field agencies dedicating resources to furthering this large-scale investigation that unfortunately now spreads internationally. Just in the past two weeks, the names of 5 workers having credible allegations of child sexual abuse have been brought to light, bringing the total number of identified perpetrators to approximately 840 (40% of these are/were workers) within our fellowship. There are over 22 countries with survivors reaching out for care.

Since the AFTT investigator hotline was established last year, the average number of perpetrators being reported is over 2 perpetrators per day. Statistically according to criminal justice researchers, the average perpetrator has [number redacted, pending verification] victims, so within our fellowship that would project to be an astounding number of victims (the vast majority never report their abuse). Even if no more perpetrators were identified in our fellowship to add to the victim number, today there are likely over [number redacted, pending verification] victims (some still attending meetings while others have left, and some now deceased) that were abused from within our fellowship. Additionally, each week more and more evidence is brought to light that every single overseer in our ministry has had knowledge of perpetrators and/or deliberately and knowingly moved multiple perpetrators around the states and world to protect perpetrators and conceal abuse. This has enabled perpetrators to sexually abuse more and more children. The systematic cover-up of these crimes, and the fact that brother workers and overseers “handled” these situations by moving perpetrators from one area to another with no communication to notify families of the risk they were allowing into their homes is what has led to the sense of betrayal that many of us are feeling and makes this so infuriating. For those in authority to say “we didn’t know how serious CSA and its aftereffects on victims is” is both disingenuous and ridiculous – anyone with any sense of morality knows that crimes against children are heinous and criminal – ignorance is no excuse. If they did not think it was serious, then why were perpetrators moved?!?

In addition to the astounding number of perpetrators in our fellowship, there is a continuing focus on including them in fellowship meetings without any regard for survivors who may also be attending the meeting. Expecting a survivor to have any interactions with a perpetrator or individual with credible allegations in meetings, usually with a denial that any abuse occurred at all (or worse yet, that since the abuse happened years ago it is not relevant), is inexcusable. It is very traumatizing for any survivor to be in meeting with a perpetrator and we must take a zero- tolerance stance.

Statistically 1 in 4 girls and 1 in 6 boys are sexually abused before the age of 18 years old. So, the probability of having survivors in every fellowship meeting is high. 90% of children that are sexually abused know their abuser and the abuser is usually trusted by the family. In light of these statistics, the effort that is being put into keeping perpetrators in meeting, without full disclosure, thereby putting our young people at risk, is mind boggling.

One of the friends recently questioned why the potential redemptive story of these individuals, who have committed such atrocities, is so important to this ministry? It is a very fair question. Yes, all souls are of immeasurable value, yet does that mean that the souls of these individuals are of more importance or of more value than that of those whose innocence they stole? To not address the issues in a transparent manner, and to not hold a zero-tolerance stance facilitates perpetrator access to additional victims. It pushes the souls of victims farther away from the community they should be receiving communal care from. Imagine if we put that same type of effort into making meetings safe for survivors and supporting their healing!

Are perpetrators more important than the many families, both young and old, that are leaving this fellowship in droves? Can we have a conversation about the large number of families that are reported to have left our fellowship in AZ primarily because the ministry refuses to take a zero- tolerance stance on allowing perpetrators in fellowship meetings? If Arizona is too far away, perhaps we can discuss the families that have left here in CA (we personally know many of them)? No, what we are hearing, though perhaps not directly but rather through worker’s parts in meetings or communications, is that those leaving are “bitter”, that they were “dead wood”, or that this is the great “falling away” that we read about in the Bible. In reality, they are leaving because of an unresponsive ministry that has chosen to circle the wagons and maintain the status quo and continue to protect perpetrators and not acknowledge and deal with the current crisis – bitterness and hardness of heart have nothing to do with it.

Another refrain we often hear is “just stay off the internet” which frankly is an outdated response because of the times we live in and how information is now shared. Most workers have both a computer and a smart phone. Telling people to stay off the internet is equivalent to telling them to not listen to the news during a war or not search up the weather forecast or doppler radar during a tornado warning in a bad storm. When people do learn of even the basic details and magnitude of this crisis within our fellowship, they are taken aback, shocked, and angry that this is not being discussed openly. No communication is in and of itself communication. Lack of communication by those who call themselves shepherds of the sheep just deepens the feeling that secrets are being kept. For those who do know what is happening it deepens the sense of betrayal and loss of trust. We cannot keep putting our heads in the sand and pretend that “all is well.”

If we don’t address the past, it will repeat itself in the future (which has been true in this fellowship). We have received reports of worker abuse going back over 100 years (family members reporting abuse of loved ones that have already passed away). We have survivors in their 90’s that have reported for the first time in their life! Imagine carrying those wounds around your whole life!!! Reporting is the first step to healing, and it is tragic that so many haven’t felt safe enough to speak out until now and finally begin their healing journey.

When we received the e-mail asking whether we were open to having workers stay in our home during special meetings, it hit us like a ton of bricks. The unfortunate reality is that we now must question if workers have allegations before agreeing to have them stay with us or welcome them into our home, as we cannot trust that such individuals have been removed. This is a huge problem.

We keep holding on to hope that we will begin to see increased awareness and strengthening of purpose to address this massive crisis through implementation of CSA/trauma training (beyond Ministry Safe which just scratches the surface) and listening sessions/elders/wives’ meetings to help support one another as more and more information comes out. We are hopeful that at very least a discussion amongst all the worker staff occurred during the workers’ meeting at Casa Grande, AZ. Can someone tell us if there was any discussion amongst the staff about this massive worldwide crisis? Was there discussion about how to come together as a ministry to support the countless survivors and their families including adopting and truly adhering to a zero-tolerance policy regarding alleged and confirmed perpetrators? If there was a discussion, we would love to know about the outcomes, what was shared, and what the action plan is.

We have been waiting over a year for meaningful, substantive change to even begin.

Instead, we keep hearing that workers here at home and across the U.S. are telling people “It’s time to move on” or provide the dismissive “they are bitter/hard” rationale for any who are struggling or who have left. Do you understand how triggering this is for survivors to hear? Many survivors report that while being abused, threats were made to them to not tell anyone and that no one would believe them anyways even if they did. By saying “It’s time to move on” or “they are just bitter/hard”, this echoes the voice of abusers and further victimizes survivors as they continue to struggle with the eternal wounds of abuse, and reinforces that they indeed are not being believed. The average age for disclosure of child sexual assault is 52 years of age, and 86% of CSA goes unreported. The result in our faith is a long list of survivors, spanning generations, with intense trauma histories being shamed and silenced.

For the sake of our survivors, our young people, and the sake of the ministry, we cannot continue to address CSA in the same manner the ministry has become accustomed to. Those in authority (brother workers/overseers, and sister workers at their direction) that have made, and continue to make, damaging decisions about perpetrators are still in positions of authority and their actions (or inaction) continues to push souls away. Unfortunately, the current action/inaction of the ministry makes it appear that the intention of the ministry is to continue down the same path it has for 100+ years.

We have made the difficult decision to no longer have an open home for the ministry. We love and plan to continue having a fellowship meeting in our home, however, we will not be attending Gospel meetings, special meetings, or conventions. We cannot in good conscience support the ministry with our presence, nor financially support the current ministry as they continue to not address the crisis at hand; instead we will help fund survivor treatment and care. We firmly stand with our survivors and do not believe perpetrators should be allowed in fellowship meetings.

This is why we both did not attend Special Meetings this year, along with many others. Attendance of Gospel meetings and special meetings gives a false impression that everything and everyone is ok. Does this mean we feel all in the ministry are to blame? No, not at all. We love and continue to pray for those honest hearts in the ministry who have been a spiritual help to us and our families in the past. We hurt for those in the ministry who feel grieved and yet are unable to take a stand in this crisis that would be contrary to the stance of those that are in authority for fear of losing their place in the work for speaking up for survivors. Our trust has been betrayed by those leading the ministry not just in our region, but throughout the states as we are one fellowship looking to one ministry.

We do not agree with how the ministry is handling this crisis.

If any are interested in further conversation regarding the contents of this letter, or discussing strategies the ministry could use to address this crisis, or references regarding any data in this letter, please feel free to contact us.

With much love and concern,

Ben Bolin, School Psychologist and Dr. Natalie Bolin, DSW, LCSW

[Phone numbers redacted by WINGS]

Book Recommendations:

1. Tear Down This Wall of Silence: Dealing with Sexual Abuse in Our Churches by Dale Ingraham.

2. Predators: Pedophiles, Rapist and Other Sex Offenders by Dr. Anna Salter *this is a very difficult book to read-trigger warning.

3. The Body Keeps the Score by Dr. Bessel Van der Kolk

4. Redeeming Power: Understanding Authority and Abuse in the Church by Dr. Diane Langberg

5. A Church Called TOV: Forming a Goodness Culture That Resists Abuses of Power and Promotes Healing by Scot McKnight and Laura Barringer

Website Links (information is verified):

Wings for Truth- www.wingsfortruth.info

Advocates For The Truth (AFTT)- www.advocatesforthetruth.com

Connected and Concerned Friends (chat app by invitation): https://connected-and-concerned-friends.mn.co/share/CkJfGykaM-yAtRZj

Here are a few links to some of the media coverage:

January 2024

1. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-66449988.amp

February 2024

1. FBI: https://forms.fbi.gov/2×2

2. Vice- https://www.vice.com/en/article/88x7zp/fbi-investigating-an-insular-nameless-religious-group-undergoing-sexual-abuse-reckoning

3. BBC article: https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-68361054

4. Media from Daily Dot in regards to Scott Rausher https://www.dailydot.com/news/church-leader-likes-facebook-archie-content/  

April 2024

1. New Zealand RNZ: https://www.rnz.co.nz/national/programmes/morningreport/audio/2018935415/secret-sect-investigated-over-historical-sexual-abuse  

2. Yankton Daily Press and Dakotan Newspaper Article: https://www.yankton.net/community/article_c8ba7a62-febf-11ee-a2ac-37fecd43f35d.html  or can be accessed at: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1m5fEsIfJSeSWwTHiSeYXu7_yoTcC4yYHKraHsOin1oc/edit

3. FBI investigating Two by Twos for historical child sexual abuse claims, including in Australia- https://www.abc.net.au/news/2024-04-28/fbi-investigating-historical-sex-abuse-claims-against-two -by-two/103767698

Waupaca County State of Wisconsin vs. Evan Q Byers

This case has not been concluded. Unless a judgment of conviction is entered, the defendant is presumed innocent of all charges.

Evan Byers was in the work in Wisconsin 1994-2001. He married in 2003.

He faces three counts relating to 2000-2001:

• Repeated Sexual Assault of Same Child (3 or more 1st degree acts)
• 2nd Degree Sexual Assault of Child
• Child Enticement-Sexual Contact

A preliminary hearing is scheduled for 10.30 am May 10, 2024.

https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/national/515427/sect-leaders-tried-for-three-years-to-get-member-to-admit-guilt-victim

Amy Williams, Journalist 7:33 am on 29 April 2024 

Warning: This story discusses details of sexual abuse

A New Zealand woman who as a child was sexually abused by a member of a secretive sect under investigation by the FBI says the religious group’s leaders spent three years trying to get the man to admit his guilt before advising her to go to the police.

The man was found guilty at trial in 2017 for abuse that began in the 1990s, spent time in jail, was placed on the sex offender register and has since left the nameless sect.

The sect has apologised to any victims for its mishandling of abuse in the past, and said it encourages its people to report abuse to police. 

Natalie*, who is now in her 40s, said the abuse was crippling and she lived with chronic illness.

She grew up in the sect, and her abuser was also part of the religious group with no name.

The abuse started when she was 12 years old and at 17 she ran away from home to escape the regular visitor.

By the time she disclosed the abuse to her parents, Natalie was an adult with children of her own.

“It wasn’t until after I disclosed, they all just went, ‘Oh we see it now’,” she said.

“It’s taught … it’s there from the moment you’re born the way things are, the world is unsafe out there but within the fold it’s safe and nobody would harm a child in there because they’re living by the Bible.”

The sect has 2500 members and 60 ministers in New Zealand, meets in homes and has no property, nor an official name – but is commonly known as Two by Twos or The Truth.

Its itinerant ministers, called Workers, travel in pairs and stay in members’ homes – the sect says these ministers are now police-vetted and trained in keeping children safe.

Natalie said when she disclosed the abuse more than 10 years ago, the sect’s leaders spent years trying to resolve the matter in-house.

“They got involved and for three years there was quite a bit of backwards and forwards, with him denying any wrongdoing. They’d gotten to the point where they said, ‘We can’t do any more; he’s refusing help.’

“They said, ‘There’s not much more we can do until you go to the police.’ “

She reported the abuse to the police and the man was eventually found guilty and jailed.

But she said a “purity” culture based on a patriarchal structure meant her immediate family was treated badly by some of the sect’s ministers.

“They’ve had Workers come into their home that won’t look at them, won’t talk to them because of what I’ve done to this ‘innocent’ man. Even if you’re still in the church it will cost you dearly to speak out or have somebody else speak out.”

The sect has been active in New Zealand for more than a century. Spokesperson Wayne Dean said they are a group of people with a common belief in the fundamental teachings of Jesus in the New Testament, and their statement of beliefs were based on the gospel of Matthew.

“We seek to live a quiet and peaceful life amongst our fellow men, hoping to show a good example of Christian living,” he said in an email.

Dean had confirmed police in New Zealand were investigating at least one former minister for historical abuse and the group was aware of 14 cases of allegations against members.

“When a complaint of historical sexual abuse is brought to our attention, we encourage the victim/survivor to report it to the police – the incident is dealt with as required by the law and the alleged offender is stood down from attending any meetings pending investigations.”

The group took every complaint seriously, Dean said.

“Unfortunately, there have been some amongst us that have given in to the desires of their sinful nature and in darkness and secrecy have abused the innocent. Like the rest of society, we are appalled by this and would never condone such behaviour.”

Jillian Hishon runs a hotline for people linked to the sect to report abuse. 

Australian victim advocate Jillian Hishon ran a hotline for people linked to the sect to report abuse and said RNZ’s stories had helped more New Zealanders to come forward in the past week.

She was concerned the sect was not doing enough to prevent abuse and help people report historic or ongoing abuse.

“This is something that every single Worker should be banging a drum about.

“In my opinion, they should have just stopped all their meetings and conventions and everything, and sorted all this out and … put across [to] people that they were serious about clearing this up. They’re not doing that.”

A current insider – who RNZ has agreed not to identify – was also concerned about how the sect’s was responding to cases of historic abuse – specifically the lack of information for members and still allowing ministers to stay in homes with children.

“If we’re going to have lasting change among us it has to be influenced from inside and outside. If I leave, I don’t have as much clout…so I haven’t left for that reason. There are things in our way that are really good and there are things in our way that have to change.”

Natalie said she believed things could have been different, had her family and abuser not been in the sect.

“If I hadn’t have been in the church it may have been quite different, the disclosure, the way I handled it. Who was going to believe me – that a professing man would do that?”

* Former members spoke to RNZ on condition of anonymity – names have been changed

Where to get help:

• NZ Police
• Victim Support 0800 842 846
• Rape Crisis 0800 88 33 00
• Rape Prevention Education
• Empowerment Trust
• HELP Call 24/7 (Auckland): 09 623 1700, (Wellington): 04 801 6655 – push 0 at the menu
• Safe to talk: a 24/7 confidential helpline for survivors, support people and those with harmful sexual behaviour 0800044334
• Male Survivors Aotearoa
• Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests (SNAP) 022 344 0496

If it is an emergency and you feel like you or someone else is at risk, call 111.

---

WINGS Note: This report relates to previous WINGS posts:

Eric Walter Smith – Nelson, New Zealand: convicted of 12 child abuse charges

Victim Impact Statement (Eric Smith, Nelson NZ)

Overseer Wayne Dean recently told the media “the church encouraged any victims of historical sexual abuse to go to the police”. In this case the victim relived the abuse while reporting to the police and relived it again through a lengthy jury trial at an enormous cost to her own wellbeing.

After all this the workers have still not publicly backed the Court verdict. Accordingly, a number of friends in the area continue to cast aspersions on the victim, despite the Court verdicts.

Religious sect’s public meetings upset former member

https://www.thepost.co.nz/nz-news/350261275/religious-sects-public-meetings-upset-former-member

Alecia Rousseau May 1, 2024

The group meets twice a week in the hall at the Senior Citizens Association.
WARWICK SMITH / MANAWATŪ STANDARD

A former member of a sect operating under “secrecy and control” is appalled they are holding public meetings at community facilities.

The man, who spoke only on the condition of anonymity, said he was shocked when he received an invitation in his Palmerston North mailbox from the church known as the Two by Twos or The Truth.

The group had been operating in New Zealand and overseas for many years, and RNZ recently revealed former church members were being investigated by the FBI for historical sexual offences.

A spokesperson for the sect acknowledged there had been harm caused in the past, but said they were now getting “behind the 8 ball” and putting protocols in place to keep people safe.

The former member, who was originally from Dannevirke, made a “public stand” and joined the group more than 30 years ago.

He was eventually ex-communicated but his parents remained in the non-denominational Christian group.

“I got involved in social credit politics and they didn’t like this, so I had to chose … I got kicked out.”

He said as a result his relationship with his mother and father completely broke down.

He was trespassed from seeing his mum, and when his father died he had no say in his burial or funeral arrangements.

“You wouldn’t believe what they did to my Mum … I can’t even talk about it.

“They didn’t even speak Dad’s name at his funeral.”

He said the group’s principles were close to that of Exclusive Brethren’s and the religion was secretive, isolated and “very controlling”.

“They get you along to these meetings and after a few they take you aside and ask if you want to join.

“Then you’re clinched.”

He said once you took a public stand you were asked to live by a new set of rules.

“Woman can’t cut their hair, there is no association with others outside the sect … no television.

“My dear Mum and her neighbour were good friends, but she wasn’t allowed contact as they are considered worldlings or dirty.”

The group was gathering twice a week at the Senior Citizens Association, and he said it was not an appropriate venue for the public meetings.

“That’s what gets me, it’s where the elderly meet … they are more likely to be convinced by them [to join].”

A spokesperson for the association, however, said the venue was hired exclusively by the group and none of its members were on site at the time.

The former member said he went to several house meetings where two pastors would teach the word of God and stay in members’ homes.

He never witnessed any sexual abuse, but said if a child “interrupted the word of God [during a house meeting] they got taken outside for a whack”.

Debbie Chamberlain, a minister for group, confirmed they were holding meetings at the Senior Citizens Association hall.

The invitation said the gatherings were held to “awaken a deeper interest” in God and the Bible, and to help unbelievers find faith.

Chamberlain said she was sorry to those who had experienced harm in the past and although she did not know the former member and his parents personally, it was likely his story was true.

But, they had made changes to the way they operated, and she said rather than controlling and coercive, they looked to Jesus to guide them.

They had “values” they lived by, and each meeting involved her and another minister preaching while people sat and listened.

“We have no affiliation to a church … we just want people to get to know Jesus.”

A fellowship group also met in homes on a Sunday morning, and there were weekly Bible studies.

“We hope the spirit is leading people to live a simple life.”

She acknowledged the people who had been hurt, and said she hoped they were able to find peace.

A police media spokesperson said they were not aware of any complaints regarding the group or its meetings, “but would encourage anyone who may have concerns to let us know”.

WINGS Note: The authors are all meeting participants. They fear backlash from writing this. It has been sent to all Australian overseers.

---

29th April 2024

Recently, the overseer of Qld issued a statement regarding a worker who has allegations of inappropriate behaviours with children.

Unfortunately, the overseer’s statement contains misinformation. The statement was published on his behalf via workers in regional areas and then through unwitting Elders to the general fellowship. The overseer has refused to respond to many emailed communications to him from members of the church regarding this matter, therefore we felt that a public response was our only choice to make it known that there are inconsistencies in his statement.

We, the families of some of the victims, would like to correct the misrepresentations. Our information has been obtained from correspondence and a face-to-face meeting with the Detective Senior Constable from the Queensland Police Child Abuse and Sexual Crimes Group.

For those who have ongoing concerns regarding the worker’s alleged behaviour, we hope the following information helps provide clarity.

The overseer’s full statement read:

This is to inform everyone that for the second time XXXXX XXXXX has been investigated by the police and thoroughly so, without any charges being laid and the investigation is to proceed no further. None of the allegations made against XXXXX have been substantiated or confirmed and there is no credible evidence that he has ever harmed a child. So we don’t have any reasonable grounds for restricting XXXXX from attending any meetings.

We address the misinformation below:

1 . This is not the second investigation against XXXXX. The current investigation is a continuation of an investigation that began several years prior.

2. The investigation has not been completed.

3. It is correct that no charges have been laid, however it should also be added that this statement is only true up to this point in time.

4. It is misleading to state that the investigation is to proceed no further. The investigation is not closed, it is ongoing. As new information is continued to be obtained, the allegations of harm to children will be continued to be investigated.

5. While it is true that none of the allegations have been “substantiated or confirmed” to any legal standards of proof, the Police have taken all the allegations from children, their families, and the wider community, seriously. According to the police, some allegations clearly fall within the legal definition of causing harm to children. Unfortunately, many victims are unable, or do not wish to come forward, or do not wish to provide evidence in criminal proceedings. The reasons for this are well documented. This does not make their allegations any less credible.

6. The overseer suggests that there is no credible evidence that XXXXX has harmed a child. The police have a number of allegations and witness statements. Some of those statements and evidence do not meet the prosecutorial standard required for a conviction, however each statement helps provide a clear picture of a sustained pattern of behaviour. Regardless of the information collected by the police, there are also multiple witnesses that have brought their accounts before the overseers and workers. Unfortunately, the overseers and workers have not given credence to the victims. Rather, the opposite is true.

7. It is erroneous to suggest there are no reasonable grounds to prevent XXXXX from attending meetings. The statement does not state whether the intention is in private or public places, however, there are reasonable grounds to prevent XXXXX from attending public religious services. It is actually unreasonable for him to attend.

These grounds relate to; the purpose to alleviate the potential risk of harm to children, and the obligation to keep children safe.

These grounds are based on the legal requirements according to QLD law: Failing to take steps to protect children from sexual offenders is an offence.

• A person in a position of power or responsibility within an institution to reduce or remove a known risk of sexual offending against a child by an adult associated with an institution.
• The failure to protect offence applies if you are 18 or older and associated with an institution that has children in its care, supervision or control.
• You know there is a significant risk that another adult also associated with the institution (or who is a regulated volunteer) will commit a sexual offence against a child or children.
• You have the power or responsibility to reduce or remove the risk but wilfully or negligently fail to reduce or remove the risk.

The grounds to exclude XXXXX from meetings is also stipulated within the ‘zero- tolerance’ policy statements written. This policy was and signed personally by all Australian (except WA) and New Zealand overseers, and issued publicly in 2023 

• The correspondence from the overseers’ states that workers will ‘listen’ and ‘believe’ victims who states allegations of child sexual assault.
• The correspondence also says: “There is no place for people who have harmed children in our meetings and conventions; we ask any individual with a history of causing harm, or allegations, or convictions not to attend. This includes public gospel meeting”. 

We would also like to remind overseers that some years ago, when XXXXX was sent to labour in SA, the overseer of SA considered XXXXX’s behaviour around children so disturbing, he removed this worker from the ministry. The SA overseer sent the worker back to Qld on the understanding that he would not be permitted back into the ministry. Unfortunately, and possibly illegally, the worker was allowed back into the ministry by Qld overseers. If the behaviour was considered to be a risk to children then, it should still be considered a risk to children now.

While the statement from the overseer insinuates that the matter is closed, it is not. There is no statute of limitations to report child sexual abuse, therefore victims and their families can still come forward when they are ready. We know that the average time for a victim to disclose child sexual abuse is 23.9 years. Men often take longer to disclose than women. Some victims never disclose.

If you have further information about XXXXX, or any other alleged child sex offences, including grooming, and even if you think it is insignificant, please contact Queensland Police, and more specifically, please contact Child Abuse and Sexual Crimes Group. This also includes reporting those who have failed their legal duty of care to report any possible or alleged breaches.

Please also, consider reporting your story to The Brave Truth Australia & New Zealand, so that your information can be added to their database, and you can receive support and advice. Specific contact details for the Detective in charge can also be obtained from The Brave Truth’, ph 0489 994 566.

Signed,

A group of concerned families and survivors.

https://www.abc.net.au/news/2024-04-28/fbi-investigating-historical-sex-abuse-claims-against-two-by-two/103767698

In a joint statement, the sect’s Australian leaders Malcolm Clapham, Graeme Dalton, Wayne Dean, Trevor Joll, Alan Mitchell, Steven Thorpe, who are based across several states, told the ABC they took allegations of child sexual abuse seriously.

“We are aware of some historic cases where individuals who were respected within the fellowship abused people’s trust,” they said.

“We acknowledge that these matters were not always appropriately addressed in the past, and we are truly sorry for any immeasurable long-term damage to victims.

“We have learnt from these experiences and are constantly reviewing our current practices to keep children safe in our fellowship.”

They said their intention is to partner with an expert external organisation to review their “policies and procedures and provide independent, unbiased advice and recommendations, particularly in relation to dealing with allegations received from third parties where information can be lacking and difficult to substantiate”.

---

WINGS Note:

The table below shows some of the key events that have created publicity in Australia. Questions some ask are why did it take so long for overseers to promulgate policies, and are the policies being implemented thoroughly.

2008	WINGS was established with representatives from USA, Canada and Australia. https://wingsfortruth.info/
2012	WINGS published a transcript of a sermon by New Zealand worker Graham Thompson, well known in Australia, which provided clear guidance on dealing with child abuse. https://wingsfortruth.info/responding-to-csa/sermon-by-graham-thompson/
2012	Victorian State Government commenced an enquiry into the Handling of Child Abuse by Religious and Other Organisations. The report was published in 2013. https://www.parliament.vic.gov.au/get-involved/inquiries/inquiry-into-the-handling-of-child-abuse-by-religious-and-other-organisations/
2013	A Code of Conduct was published by WINGS, developed with the support of several workers and friends, and issued to provide a model for overseers to use in their various territories. https://wingsfortruth.info/2023/04/01/csa-code-of-conduct-2013/
2013	The Australian Federal Government commenced a Royal Commission Inquiry into CSA in Australian Institutions. The final report was published in 2017 https://www.childabuseroyalcommission.gov.au/
2013	Publicity in the Melbourne Age about abuse within the fellowship. https://wingsfortruth.info/2013/09/25/articles-in-the-age-melbourne-australia/
2019	60 Minutes Programme in Australia had a 25 minute feature on child abuse cases within the fellowship in Australia. https://www.youtube.com/watch
2019 to 2021	Child Safety Codes and Policies were issued in Australian States Victoria, Tasmania, NSW, ACT, South Australia, Northern Territory, West Australia and Queensland. https://wingsfortruth.info/resources/
2023	Australia/NZ Overseers’ Letter to the Church. https://wingsfortruth.info/2023/07/01/australia-nz-letter-to-the-church/
2023	Australian support group ‘The Brave Truth Australia’ created. https://wingsfortruth.info/2023/06/30/australian-support-group-created/
2023	Australia / New Zealand Overseers Create Advisory Group. https://wingsfortruth.info/2023/08/18/australasian-overseers-create-advisory-group/
2023	Convention Guidelines issued, with reminder that Child Safe Policy and Workers Code of Conduct are available on request. https://wingsfortruth.info/2023/10/26/convention-arrangements-for-australia-and-new-zealand/

Dear friends,

I am very sorry to have to write to you today about our brother Albert Clark. We have recently received knowledge of allegations against him of CSA that date to over 40 years ago. In light of this evidence, we have reported what we know to the authorities in the region where it occurred, and we feel it is best for Albert to stop being active in the ministry. Albert is in agreement with this decision.

Albert has expressed that he is sorry for any harm it has caused, directly and indirectly. I appreciate his humility and his acceptance, and we recognize that it is possible that he has never done anything of this nature since that time. At the same time, we have decided that because he has been engaged in that kind of activity, it is better for him not to be in the work now.

Any kind of sexual activity with a child is wrong, according to the law in our country and more importantly, according to God. There are no exceptions to this, and an adult is always responsible for their conduct toward a child. These kind of actions can’t be undone and they often leave psychological scars that last a lifetime. It’s not that it can’t be forgiven, but it seems that it is much better to address it and deal with it no matter how hard it is. We certainly feel for the victims, and want to be a support in the right way.

Especially if one of our workers has done something of this nature, we hope that everyone would feel free to tell us, and feel free report it to the local authorities. It is important for us to know because the workers are circulating in your homes regularly, and we want to do our part to ensure everyone’s safety. We want to remind you also that if you know about someone who is currently a minor and has been or is being abused, you are legally responsible to report it to law enforcement.

I don’t feel qualified to speak a lot about this subject of CSA, but we have learned through studying about it, and through talking with survivors and experienced professionals about it. We know that this is something that usually happens in secret, and it is very difficult to be open about it; for both the victim and the perpetrator. There is often a lot of shame and hurt associated with it. It often doesn’t come to light until many years afterwards. We try to be understanding and empathetic, but really we know that we won’t be able to truly enter into another person’s difficult and traumatic experience. We’re thankful that God understands and He wants to help us to find healing and comfort. We want to help too, and we are praying to know how to be an encouragement and help to those who are burdened by these heavy trials of life.

We believe and know that there is a path forward for every human being, that leads to life with God. No matter what we have done and no matter what has happened to us. That is the simple truth that we are devoting our life to share. We need help from Him to see that path; and we need humility, courage and self-denial to walk in it. We greatly appreciate those who help us to see the path forward, most of all Jesus who is the perfect example. There is no amount of confusion or deception that can hinder us from going forward in this way, as long as we stay close to him, and keep our eyes on him.

Your brother, Jonathan.

---

WINGS Note: This is from Johnathon Freeburn in New Brunswick, Atlantic Canada.

Albert Clark has been a worker in Halifax-Cape Breton, Nova Scotia, Canada

WINGS Note: This correspondence was marked as Confidential / Not to be distributed, as it included the name of an alleged perpetrator. The Brave Truth have redacted the sensitive details and provided permission for this post. They comment:

On the 16th February 2024, The Brave Truth started communication with Graeme Dalton, State Overseer for New South Wales, Australia with regards to an alleged perpetrator.

We have been very clear with our correspondence to the Overseers and advised previously that will make them aware when we have either 1 Police report, or 3 victim reports without a Police report so they can uphold their own policy of removing alleged perpetrators as per their letter of 1 July 2023. In this case, we have 3 Police reports and also an email in our possession of 2 other Overseers knowing of a victim/s in 2021.

It is heart-breaking for any victim-survivor to see how these cases are dealt with and also very important for the wider ‘friends’ community to understand who they are meeting with.

We are honoured to be able to advocate confidentially for victim-survivors in these situations.

---

From: The Brave Truth Aus & NZ <bravetruth@thebravetruthaunz.org>
Sent: Friday, 16 February 2024 2:31 PM
To: xxxxxxxxxxx@gmail.com; xxxxxxxxxxx@gmail.com
Subject: Confidential: XXXXX XXXXX

The Brave Truth Australia & New Zealand
PO Box 5275 MANLY Q 4179
Email: bravetruth@thebravetruthaunz.org

Confidential letter for Graeme Dalton and Lynn Sherlock only.

Not to be distributed.

Dear Graeme and Lynn,

We are writing to advise you that 3 Police Intelligence Reports have been completed concerning XXXXX XXXXX of (Western NSW). This relates to historical unlawful and indecent dealings of persons under 16 years of age. We bring this notification to you in good faith – understanding we are not personally making allegations, but passing on in a private capacity that separate reports have been made.

As leaders of your church fellowship, and in line with your published written comments, we believe you have an interest in receiving this information as you may want to take specific action.

We would appreciate your confirmation of what action you take as it is important to provide confidential feedback to those who have made the reports to us.

By privately and confidentially sharing this factual information within the protection of Qualified Privilege, we’re hopeful that it will help us all to keep children and vulnerable people safe and we want to work with you as much as possible in order to do this. We anticipate by sharing this information it will help expedite this process.

Sincerely,

Jillian Hishon (for and on behalf of many concerned survivors, friends & children)

The Brave Truth Australia & New Zealand
P.O. Box 5275 Manly Q 4179
E: bravetruth@thebravetruthaunz.org P: +61 489 994 566

---

From: The Brave Truth Aus & NZ <bravetruth@thebravetruthaunz.org>
Sent: Wednesday, 21 February 2024 2:17 PM
To: xxxxxxxxx@gmail.com xxxxxxxxxxx@gmail.com
Cc: xxxxxxxxxxxx@gmail.com
Subject: RE: Confidential: XXXXX XXXXX

Dear Graeme & Lynn,

We are following up our earlier email concerning XXXXX XXXXX as almost a week has now passed and we have not received a response from you.

We would be pleased to hear from you by close of business this Friday (23rd February 2024) that necessary steps have been taken to keep children and other victims of sexual assault safe in the fellowship. Please confirm that XXXXX XXXXX will no longer be attending any church gatherings and the relevant elders have been notified.

It is important that we are able to relay this information to all victim-survivors for them to be assured that there is zero-tolerance, as promised by all Overseers, is being enforced. All correspondence will be added to victim-survivor Police reports.

Whilst our preference is to work with you in relation to information that is supplied to us, if this does not occur, we will have no option but to take the matter further.

We look forward to hearing from you.

Sincerely, Jillian Hishon

The Brave Truth Australia & New Zealand
P.O. Box 5275 Manly Q 4179
E: bravetruth@thebravetruthaunz.org P: +61 489 994 566

---

From: Graeme Dalton <xxxxxxxxx@gmail.com>
Sent: Thursday, 22 February 2024 7:11 AM
To: The Brave Truth Aus & NZ <bravetruth@thebravetruthaunz.org>
Subject: Re: Confidential: XX

Dear Jillian

Thanks for your email and the information you have provided regarding XX.

Our intention is that we want to protect children and act on all information provided to us.

As the allegations mentioned in your email have not come directly from a survivor, I would appreciate further information in assisting us in taking action. This will enable us to comply with the Royal Commission requirements and NSW mandatory reporting requirements.

Would you please provide the following information:

1. That the survivor/s has/have given consent for me to be notified;
2. That the survivor/s has/have given permission for the matter to be raised with the alleged perpetrator;
3. The number of survivors who have made a police intelligence report;
4. The age of the survivor/s at the time of abuse;
5. Place/s where the abuse occurred;
6. The role WW in the fellowship at the time of the abuse; and
7. Timeframe of abuse.

We note your request in relation to privacy and confidentiality, and assure you that we will use this information only for the purpose of acting appropriately to safeguard children in the fellowship.

Please make any survivors aware that we have an application in to the redress scheme and have received ministerial approval, and that I am at all times willing to speak to any survivor with a mediator present, if they feel comfortable.

Regards,

Graeme Dalton

---

From: The Brave Truth Aus & NZ <bravetruth@thebravetruthaunz.org>
Sent: Friday, 23 February 2024 3:09 PM
To: ‘Graeme Dalton’ <xxxxxxxxxxx@gmail.com>
Cc: xxxxxxxxxxxxx@gmail.com
Subject: RE: Confidential: XX

Dear Graeme,

Thank you for your reply to my emails.

As a result of strict confidentiality parameters here at The Brave Truth, there is very little information that can be given other than what is shared in our standard correspondence.

We appreciate your wish to comply with the Royal Commission requirements, and NSW Mandatory reporting.

In response to your requests for information, in general terms:

• We only notify you (or other Overseers) about an alleged perpetrator if when we have received full consent from the victim-survivor(s) who reported that same perpetrator to us. This is not always the case, there are instances where the victim-survivor is too fearful for this next step to be taken yet.
• We assure you that the victim-survivor understands that matter will be raised with the alleged perpetrator, and the expectation is the perpetrator will be removed from fellowship as per the statement from Overseers on 1 July 2023.
• We can and will share with you how many victim-survivors have made police reports regarding a perpetrator.
• It is inappropriate for us to give you the exact age of the victim at the time of the abuse, we can confirm if they’re under the age of 18. And if consented by the victim-survivor, we may be able to clarify if they were under the age of 10, for example.
• Disclosing the place of abuse is not required. Where we can, we may disclose if it was in a meeting setting versus a social setting.
• We can only name the role the perpetrator had in the fellowship at the time of the abuse, if the victim -survivor remembers and consents to its release.
• Timeframe of abuse is also unnecessary, but if the victim-survivor consents to this being released, we will do so.

Regarding XXXXX XXXXX, we have 3 Police Intelligence reports against him. All victim-survivors in this instance were under 18 years of age at the time of the abuse, which occurred in both Queensland & New South Wales. No other identifying information can be released.

To clarify, I would also like to assure you that we would never say there is a Police Intelligence Report if that wasn’t the case.

On the topic of Private and Confidential communications, Workers recently have proven no understanding of this legal provision, hence our letter dated 05/02/2024. This is particularly concerning in instances where Workers have immediately talked to people, disclosing information. That is very alarming in itself, but doubly alarming as they could unknowingly be speaking with a victim of that same perpetrator. It just cannot happen and because of the lax approach by a number of Workers, it has underscored how very careful The Brave Truth needs to be with what information we share. We don’t make false allegations and I can assure you, any information we share with you has come directly from a victim-survivor.

Sincerely,

Jillian Hishon

The Brave Truth Australia & New Zealand
P.O. Box 5275 Manly Q 4179
E: bravetruth@thebravetruthaunz.org
P: +61489 994 566

---

From: The Brave Truth Aus & NZ <bravetruth@thebravetruthaunz.org>
Sent: Thursday, March 7, 2024 11:02 AM
To: ‘Graeme Dalton’ < xxxxxxxx@gmail.com>
Cc: xxxxxxxxxxx@gmail.com
Subject: RE: Confidential: XX

Dear Graeme,

As it’s almost 2 weeks since I replied to your email, I would appreciate hearing from you by close of business tomorrow (8th March, 2024) that necessary steps have been taken to keep children and other victims of sexual abuse safe in the fellowship. Please confirm that XXXXX XXXXX will no longer be attending any church gatherings and the relevant elders have been notified.

It is important that we are able to relay this information to all victim-survivors – for them to be assured that there is zero-tolerance being enforced, as promised by all Overseers. All correspondence will be added to victim-survivor Police reports.

I look forward to hearing from you.

Kind Regards,

Jillian Hishon

The Brave Truth Australia & New Zealand
P.O. Box 5275
Manly Q 4179
E: bravetruth@thebravetruthaunz.org
P: +61 489 994 566

---

From: xxxxxxxxxx@gmail.com
Sent: Friday, 8 March 2024 8:11 AM
To: ‘The Brave Truth Aus & NZ’ <bravetruth@thebravetruthaunz.org>
Subject: RE: Confidential: XX

Dear Jillian,

Thanks for your email and the matter with XX is still progressing.

Kind regards,

Graeme

---

From: The Brave Truth Aus & NZ <bravetruth@thebravetruthaunz.org>
Sent: Wednesday, 13 March 2024 1:36 PM
To: xxxxxxxxxxx@gmail.com
Subject: RE: Confidential: XX

Dear Graeme,

Further to information I have shared with you earlier, Xxxxx Xxxx and Xxxxxx Xxxx were made aware of accusations against XXXXX XXXXX in 2020. 1 am in receipt of an email sent to Xxxxx on 8 August 2020, to which he replied on 10th August 2020 saying he would be making Xxxxxx Xxxx aware. They were given details of victims to contact.

Also, (NSW) Police contacted me after you’d been to see them recently. I was grateful for the opportunity to let them know about the letter written on 1 July 2023 from Australian & New Zealand Overseers with regards to contacting you if there was anything to report and exactly what part The Brave Truth plays in this and also shared information with him about the very current International FBI Investigation.

Please let me know ASAP how things are progressing with XXXXX XXXXX so I can let the victim-survivors know that this is being taken seriously.

Kind Regards,

Jillian Hishon

The Brave Truth Australia & New Zealand
P.O. Box 5275
Manly Q 4179
E: bravetruth@thebravetruthaunz.org
P: +61 489 994 566

---

From: The Brave Truth Aus & NZ<bravetruth@thebravetruthaunz.org>
Sent: Wednesday, 20 March 2024 10:14 AM
To: xxxxxxxxxx@gmail.com
Subject: RE: Confidential: XX

Dear Graeme,

Can you please advise by COB today 20th March 2024 that the necessary steps have been taken to keep children and other victims of sexual abuse safe In the fellowship. Please confirm that XXXXX XXXXX will no longer be attending any church gatherings and the relevant elders have been notified.

It is important that we are able to relay this information to all victim-survivors for them to be assured that there is zero-tolerance being enforced, as promised by all Overseers. All correspondence will be added to victim-survivor Police reports.

Kind Regards,

Jillian Hishon

The Brave Truth Australia & New Zealand
P.O. Box 5275
Manly Q 4179
E: bravetruth@thebravetruthaunz.org
P: +61 489 994 566

---

From: xxxxxxxxxx@gmail.com
Sent: Friday, 22 March 2024 1:59 PM
To: ‘The Brave Truth Aus & NZ’ <bravetruth@thebravetruthaunz.org>
Subject: RE: Confidential: XX

Dear Jillian,

In reference to this email the matter with XX is still progressing.

Kind regards,

Graeme

---

From: xxxxxxxxxxxx@gmail.com
Sent: Tuesday, April 2, 2024 2:21 PM
To: ‘The Brave Truth Aus & NZ’ <bravetruth@thebravetruthaunz.org>
Subject: re XX

Dear Jillian

I refer to our email correspondence of 22/02/2024 and 29/02/2024.
Noting that we are guided by the Royal Commission recommendations to establish plausibility, and in the absence of an allegation direct from a survivor or having further information of the nature previously requested, I am unable to take the matter further.
If you are able to provide the information requested in my email of 22/02/2024 I will review the matter.

Kind regards

Graeme

---

From: The Brave Truth AU & NZ <bravetruth@thebravetruthaunz.org>
Sent: Thursday, April 4, 2024 11:03 AM
To: xxxxxxxx@gmail.com
Cc: Wayne Dean <xxxxxxxxx@gmail.com>
Subject: Re: re XX

Dear Graeme,

Thank you for your email of 2nd April 2024.

The information we have provided from victim-survivors of xxxxxxxxxxxx is plausible, including the information about him that was provided after he was appointed as an elder, to Wayne Dean and then Graham Snow in August 2020. The matter was clearly investigated then by the relevant Overseers and some action was taken.

In relation to the recommendations of the Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse we note your reference to plausibility (Recommendation 16.52). This recommendation references the religious institution’s complaint handling policies. Other recommendations refer specifically to complaint-handling policies and procedures:

• Recommendation 16.5 – requests all religious institutions implement the 10 Child Safe Standards which reference the requirement to have effective complaint-handling policies and procedures
• Recommendation 6.6 – Standard 6 requires all religious institutions to have effective, transparent complaint-handling systems, policies and procedures in place
• Recommendation 16.41 – requires all religious institutions to make provision for family and community involvement by publishing all policies relevant to child safety on its website
• Recommendation 16.51 – all religious institutions’ complaint handling policies should require that, upon receiving a complaint of child sexual abuse, an initial risk assessment is conducted to identify and minimise any risks to children
• Recommendation 16.54 – requests religious institutions to apply the same standards for investigating complaints of child sexual abuse whether or not the subject of the complaint is a person in religious ministry

We have been advised by members of your church (a number of whom directly support TBTA) that your complaint handling policies and procedures have not been developed or published. As a result, it is unclear how complaints are handled, how investigations are conducted and how decisions are determined.

In our view, this is unsatisfactory given the seriousness of the problem in the fellowship and the comprehensive nature of the Royal Commission’s recommendations which were made over six years ago.

Unfortunately, there is little evidence at this point that child safety is embedded in any meaningful way in the leadership, governance and culture of the fellowship (Child Safe Standard No. 1 of the Royal Commission recommendations). It is also clear that there will be a progressive trust deficit if cases that are brought to your attention continue in this manner.

We acknowledge it is your crisis to manage as you see fit, however, we will let victim-survivors know your stance in this and forward this correspondence directly to the FBI to add to their investigation.

Kind Regards

Jillian Hishon & Ross Bowden

The Brave Truth Australia & New Zealand
P.O. Box 5275
Manly Q 4179
E: bravetruth@thebravetruthaunz.org
P: +61 489 994 566

---

WINGS Note: We have been advised that the workers/overseers believe that they have not been given sufficient specific information to act against the alleged perpetrator, and that even the Police reports might have insufficient details.

We encourage prompt and open communication between overseers and people reporting allegations.

From: Cynthia Liles <cynthia@aftt.org>
Date: Sun, Apr 7, 2024 at 12:40 PM
To: Kent Williston <Email redacted>, Rob Newman <Email redacted>
Cc: Lauren Rohs <Email redacted>

Kent, it has come to my attention that a Jay Wilson survivor, [Name1 redacted], has emailed you THIRTEEN times. Rob, I understand you have been cc’d on two of those. It is my understanding B has not received one response from either one of you. You are walking by the wounded and bleeding in the ditch. I’m not sure how you sleep at night.

Regarding the [Name2 redacted] allegation – no, the facts of the allegation do not need to be clarified. There is no mistake and the survivor is not an undependable source. I have confirmation [redacted] (will) further corroborate the facts of this allegation. You should know by now that I do not release the name of an alleged perpetrator unless I am confident in the merits of the allegation.

I am astounded at the lack of humanity on the part of the ministry. Surely you can do better.

Cynthia Liles
The Advocates for the Truth Team
advocatesforthetruth@gmail.com
Survivor Hotline: (503)386-4634
Contact Us — Advocates For The Truth

---

From: Rob Newman <Email redacted>
Date: Tue, Apr 9, 2024 at 9:18AM
To: Cynthia Liles cynthia@aftt.org

Cynthia,

For a number of reasons, this will be our final response to your communications. If you have information about past or ongoing criminal activity, we implore you to report it to the proper authorities. We remain willing, as always, to cooperate with the authorities in any investigations which are the result of your reports. If you choose to send us adequate details, we will report it to the authorities.

Rob

---

WINGS absolutely supports the reporting of allegations to authorities. That is necessary and appropriate. However it is not sufficient. Counselling and support for the victim and close family is necessary. The local and wider Church needs clear communication, to protect families and the integrity of all members, and in contemplation that there may be other victims. The alleged perpetrator should not attend meetings where the victim or their family or any other children may be present. The Church can not pass all responsibility to law enforcement agencies. The front line of responsibility lies with families and Church leadership – elders, workers and overseers.

Failure to act is being an accessory to a crime. Protecting children should be a priority.