WINGS Note: This correspondence was marked as Confidential / Not to be distributed, as it included the name of an alleged perpetrator. The Brave Truth have redacted the sensitive details and provided permission for this post. They comment:
On the 16th February 2024, The Brave Truth started communication with Graeme Dalton, State Overseer for New South Wales, Australia with regards to an alleged perpetrator.
We have been very clear with our correspondence to the Overseers and advised previously that will make them aware when we have either 1 Police report, or 3 victim reports without a Police report so they can uphold their own policy of removing alleged perpetrators as per their letter of 1 July 2023. In this case, we have 3 Police reports and also an email in our possession of 2 other Overseers knowing of a victim/s in 2021.
It is heart-breaking for any victim-survivor to see how these cases are dealt with and also very important for the wider ‘friends’ community to understand who they are meeting with.
We are honoured to be able to advocate confidentially for victim-survivors in these situations.
From: The Brave Truth Aus & NZ <bravetruth@thebravetruthaunz.org>
Sent: Friday, 16 February 2024 2:31 PM
To: xxxxxxxxxxx@gmail.com; xxxxxxxxxxx@gmail.com
Subject: Confidential: XXXXX XXXXX
The Brave Truth Australia & New Zealand
PO Box 5275 MANLY Q 4179
Email: bravetruth@thebravetruthaunz.org
Confidential letter for Graeme Dalton and Lynn Sherlock only.
Not to be distributed.
Dear Graeme and Lynn,
We are writing to advise you that 3 Police Intelligence Reports have been completed concerning XXXXX XXXXX of (Western NSW). This relates to historical unlawful and indecent dealings of persons under 16 years of age. We bring this notification to you in good faith – understanding we are not personally making allegations, but passing on in a private capacity that separate reports have been made.
As leaders of your church fellowship, and in line with your published written comments, we believe you have an interest in receiving this information as you may want to take specific action.
We would appreciate your confirmation of what action you take as it is important to provide confidential feedback to those who have made the reports to us.
By privately and confidentially sharing this factual information within the protection of Qualified Privilege, we’re hopeful that it will help us all to keep children and vulnerable people safe and we want to work with you as much as possible in order to do this. We anticipate by sharing this information it will help expedite this process.
Sincerely,
Jillian Hishon (for and on behalf of many concerned survivors, friends & children)
The Brave Truth Australia & New Zealand
P.O. Box 5275 Manly Q 4179
E: bravetruth@thebravetruthaunz.org P: +61 489 994 566
From: The Brave Truth Aus & NZ <bravetruth@thebravetruthaunz.org>
Sent: Wednesday, 21 February 2024 2:17 PM
To: xxxxxxxxx@gmail.com xxxxxxxxxxx@gmail.com
Cc: xxxxxxxxxxxx@gmail.com
Subject: RE: Confidential: XXXXX XXXXX
Dear Graeme & Lynn,
We are following up our earlier email concerning XXXXX XXXXX as almost a week has now passed and we have not received a response from you.
We would be pleased to hear from you by close of business this Friday (23rd February 2024) that necessary steps have been taken to keep children and other victims of sexual assault safe in the fellowship. Please confirm that XXXXX XXXXX will no longer be attending any church gatherings and the relevant elders have been notified.
It is important that we are able to relay this information to all victim-survivors for them to be assured that there is zero-tolerance, as promised by all Overseers, is being enforced. All correspondence will be added to victim-survivor Police reports.
Whilst our preference is to work with you in relation to information that is supplied to us, if this does not occur, we will have no option but to take the matter further.
We look forward to hearing from you.
Sincerely, Jillian Hishon
The Brave Truth Australia & New Zealand
P.O. Box 5275 Manly Q 4179
E: bravetruth@thebravetruthaunz.org P: +61 489 994 566
From: Graeme Dalton <xxxxxxxxx@gmail.com>
Sent: Thursday, 22 February 2024 7:11 AM
To: The Brave Truth Aus & NZ <bravetruth@thebravetruthaunz.org>
Subject: Re: Confidential: XX
Dear Jillian
Thanks for your email and the information you have provided regarding XX.
Our intention is that we want to protect children and act on all information provided to us.
As the allegations mentioned in your email have not come directly from a survivor, I would appreciate further information in assisting us in taking action. This will enable us to comply with the Royal Commission requirements and NSW mandatory reporting requirements.
Would you please provide the following information:
- That the survivor/s has/have given consent for me to be notified;
- That the survivor/s has/have given permission for the matter to be raised with the alleged perpetrator;
- The number of survivors who have made a police intelligence report;
- The age of the survivor/s at the time of abuse;
- Place/s where the abuse occurred;
- The role WW in the fellowship at the time of the abuse; and
- Timeframe of abuse.
We note your request in relation to privacy and confidentiality, and assure you that we will use this information only for the purpose of acting appropriately to safeguard children in the fellowship.
Please make any survivors aware that we have an application in to the redress scheme and have received ministerial approval, and that I am at all times willing to speak to any survivor with a mediator present, if they feel comfortable.
Regards,
Graeme Dalton
From: The Brave Truth Aus & NZ <bravetruth@thebravetruthaunz.org>
Sent: Friday, 23 February 2024 3:09 PM
To: ‘Graeme Dalton’ <xxxxxxxxxxx@gmail.com>
Cc: xxxxxxxxxxxxx@gmail.com
Subject: RE: Confidential: XX
Dear Graeme,
Thank you for your reply to my emails.
As a result of strict confidentiality parameters here at The Brave Truth, there is very little information that can be given other than what is shared in our standard correspondence.
We appreciate your wish to comply with the Royal Commission requirements, and NSW Mandatory reporting.
In response to your requests for information, in general terms:
- We only notify you (or other Overseers) about an alleged perpetrator if when we have received full consent from the victim-survivor(s) who reported that same perpetrator to us. This is not always the case, there are instances where the victim-survivor is too fearful for this next step to be taken yet.
- We assure you that the victim-survivor understands that matter will be raised with the alleged perpetrator, and the expectation is the perpetrator will be removed from fellowship as per the statement from Overseers on 1 July 2023.
- We can and will share with you how many victim-survivors have made police reports regarding a perpetrator.
- It is inappropriate for us to give you the exact age of the victim at the time of the abuse, we can confirm if they’re under the age of 18. And if consented by the victim-survivor, we may be able to clarify if they were under the age of 10, for example.
- Disclosing the place of abuse is not required. Where we can, we may disclose if it was in a meeting setting versus a social setting.
- We can only name the role the perpetrator had in the fellowship at the time of the abuse, if the victim -survivor remembers and consents to its release.
- Timeframe of abuse is also unnecessary, but if the victim-survivor consents to this being released, we will do so.
Regarding XXXXX XXXXX, we have 3 Police Intelligence reports against him. All victim-survivors in this instance were under 18 years of age at the time of the abuse, which occurred in both Queensland & New South Wales. No other identifying information can be released.
To clarify, I would also like to assure you that we would never say there is a Police Intelligence Report if that wasn’t the case.
On the topic of Private and Confidential communications, Workers recently have proven no understanding of this legal provision, hence our letter dated 05/02/2024. This is particularly concerning in instances where Workers have immediately talked to people, disclosing information. That is very alarming in itself, but doubly alarming as they could unknowingly be speaking with a victim of that same perpetrator. It just cannot happen and because of the lax approach by a number of Workers, it has underscored how very careful The Brave Truth needs to be with what information we share. We don’t make false allegations and I can assure you, any information we share with you has come directly from a victim-survivor.
Sincerely,
Jillian Hishon
The Brave Truth Australia & New Zealand
P.O. Box 5275 Manly Q 4179
E: bravetruth@thebravetruthaunz.org
P: +61489 994 566
From: The Brave Truth Aus & NZ <bravetruth@thebravetruthaunz.org>
Sent: Thursday, March 7, 2024 11:02 AM
To: ‘Graeme Dalton’ < xxxxxxxx@gmail.com>
Cc: xxxxxxxxxxx@gmail.com
Subject: RE: Confidential: XX
Dear Graeme,
As it’s almost 2 weeks since I replied to your email, I would appreciate hearing from you by close of business tomorrow (8th March, 2024) that necessary steps have been taken to keep children and other victims of sexual abuse safe in the fellowship. Please confirm that XXXXX XXXXX will no longer be attending any church gatherings and the relevant elders have been notified.
It is important that we are able to relay this information to all victim-survivors – for them to be assured that there is zero-tolerance being enforced, as promised by all Overseers. All correspondence will be added to victim-survivor Police reports.
I look forward to hearing from you.
Kind Regards,
Jillian Hishon
The Brave Truth Australia & New Zealand
P.O. Box 5275
Manly Q 4179
E: bravetruth@thebravetruthaunz.org
P: +61 489 994 566
From: xxxxxxxxxx@gmail.com
Sent: Friday, 8 March 2024 8:11 AM
To: ‘The Brave Truth Aus & NZ’ <bravetruth@thebravetruthaunz.org>
Subject: RE: Confidential: XX
Dear Jillian,
Thanks for your email and the matter with XX is still progressing.
Kind regards,
Graeme
From: The Brave Truth Aus & NZ <bravetruth@thebravetruthaunz.org>
Sent: Wednesday, 13 March 2024 1:36 PM
To: xxxxxxxxxxx@gmail.com
Subject: RE: Confidential: XX
Dear Graeme,
Further to information I have shared with you earlier, Xxxxx Xxxx and Xxxxxx Xxxx were made aware of accusations against XXXXX XXXXX in 2020. 1 am in receipt of an email sent to Xxxxx on 8 August 2020, to which he replied on 10th August 2020 saying he would be making Xxxxxx Xxxx aware. They were given details of victims to contact.
Also, (NSW) Police contacted me after you’d been to see them recently. I was grateful for the opportunity to let them know about the letter written on 1 July 2023 from Australian & New Zealand Overseers with regards to contacting you if there was anything to report and exactly what part The Brave Truth plays in this and also shared information with him about the very current International FBI Investigation.
Please let me know ASAP how things are progressing with XXXXX XXXXX so I can let the victim-survivors know that this is being taken seriously.
Kind Regards,
Jillian Hishon
The Brave Truth Australia & New Zealand
P.O. Box 5275
Manly Q 4179
E: bravetruth@thebravetruthaunz.org
P: +61 489 994 566
From: The Brave Truth Aus & NZ<bravetruth@thebravetruthaunz.org>
Sent: Wednesday, 20 March 2024 10:14 AM
To: xxxxxxxxxx@gmail.com
Subject: RE: Confidential: XX
Dear Graeme,
Can you please advise by COB today 20th March 2024 that the necessary steps have been taken to keep children and other victims of sexual abuse safe In the fellowship. Please confirm that XXXXX XXXXX will no longer be attending any church gatherings and the relevant elders have been notified.
It is important that we are able to relay this information to all victim-survivors for them to be assured that there is zero-tolerance being enforced, as promised by all Overseers. All correspondence will be added to victim-survivor Police reports.
Kind Regards,
Jillian Hishon
The Brave Truth Australia & New Zealand
P.O. Box 5275
Manly Q 4179
E: bravetruth@thebravetruthaunz.org
P: +61 489 994 566
From: xxxxxxxxxx@gmail.com
Sent: Friday, 22 March 2024 1:59 PM
To: ‘The Brave Truth Aus & NZ’ <bravetruth@thebravetruthaunz.org>
Subject: RE: Confidential: XX
Dear Jillian,
In reference to this email the matter with XX is still progressing.
Kind regards,
Graeme
From: xxxxxxxxxxxx@gmail.com
Sent: Tuesday, April 2, 2024 2:21 PM
To: ‘The Brave Truth Aus & NZ’ <bravetruth@thebravetruthaunz.org>
Subject: re XX
Dear Jillian
I refer to our email correspondence of 22/02/2024 and 29/02/2024.
Noting that we are guided by the Royal Commission recommendations to establish plausibility, and in the absence of an allegation direct from a survivor or having further information of the nature previously requested, I am unable to take the matter further.
If you are able to provide the information requested in my email of 22/02/2024 I will review the matter.
Kind regards
Graeme
From: The Brave Truth AU & NZ <bravetruth@thebravetruthaunz.org>
Sent: Thursday, April 4, 2024 11:03 AM
To: xxxxxxxx@gmail.com
Cc: Wayne Dean <xxxxxxxxx@gmail.com>
Subject: Re: re XX
Dear Graeme,
Thank you for your email of 2nd April 2024.
The information we have provided from victim-survivors of xxxxxxxxxxxx is plausible, including the information about him that was provided after he was appointed as an elder, to Wayne Dean and then Graham Snow in August 2020. The matter was clearly investigated then by the relevant Overseers and some action was taken.
In relation to the recommendations of the Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse we note your reference to plausibility (Recommendation 16.52). This recommendation references the religious institution’s complaint handling policies. Other recommendations refer specifically to complaint-handling policies and procedures:
- Recommendation 16.5 – requests all religious institutions implement the 10 Child Safe Standards which reference the requirement to have effective complaint-handling policies and procedures
- Recommendation 6.6 – Standard 6 requires all religious institutions to have effective, transparent complaint-handling systems, policies and procedures in place
- Recommendation 16.41 – requires all religious institutions to make provision for family and community involvement by publishing all policies relevant to child safety on its website
- Recommendation 16.51 – all religious institutions’ complaint handling policies should require that, upon receiving a complaint of child sexual abuse, an initial risk assessment is conducted to identify and minimise any risks to children
- Recommendation 16.54 – requests religious institutions to apply the same standards for investigating complaints of child sexual abuse whether or not the subject of the complaint is a person in religious ministry
We have been advised by members of your church (a number of whom directly support TBTA) that your complaint handling policies and procedures have not been developed or published. As a result, it is unclear how complaints are handled, how investigations are conducted and how decisions are determined.
In our view, this is unsatisfactory given the seriousness of the problem in the fellowship and the comprehensive nature of the Royal Commission’s recommendations which were made over six years ago.
Unfortunately, there is little evidence at this point that child safety is embedded in any meaningful way in the leadership, governance and culture of the fellowship (Child Safe Standard No. 1 of the Royal Commission recommendations). It is also clear that there will be a progressive trust deficit if cases that are brought to your attention continue in this manner.
We acknowledge it is your crisis to manage as you see fit, however, we will let victim-survivors know your stance in this and forward this correspondence directly to the FBI to add to their investigation.
Kind Regards
Jillian Hishon & Ross Bowden
The Brave Truth Australia & New Zealand
P.O. Box 5275
Manly Q 4179
E: bravetruth@thebravetruthaunz.org
P: +61 489 994 566
WINGS Note: We have been advised that the workers/overseers believe that they have not been given sufficient specific information to act against the alleged perpetrator, and that even the Police reports might have insufficient details.
We encourage prompt and open communication between overseers and people reporting allegations.